California Governor Gavin Newsom posted on X that President Donald Trump has failed America on AI safety and that the state is moving forward with mandatory safety standards and real accountability, according to the message, which shared a video and linked to new recommendations for California’s AI framework. The post from California drew hundreds of replies, with many users pointing to Newsom’s 2024 veto of a major AI safety bill and the state’s record on large projects, while experts connected to the recommendations offered support for the proposals.
The video shows Newsom seated at a table in a suit, speaking to the camera. He states that “two-thirds of all the large AI companies in terms of market cap are in the state of California,” calling the state “the center of this debate” and “the center of the responsibility to address” the issue “in the absence of any federal leadership.”
He refers to recent incidents at Microsoft, the FAA, the NSA, banks, and Apple, asking, “Is this all coincidental?” and whether “there’s no one at the helm taking responsibility.” He adds that the administration’s main step has been “a desire to preempt states like California to actually create guardrails.”
The remarks accompany the November 18 release of recommendations from the California Governor’s Office to strengthen the state’s AI framework. These include baseline safety standards, mandatory third-party oversight, emergency shutdown authority, and limits on recursive self-improvement.
The proposals follow a September executive order and have not yet been enacted as law. Newsom vetoed SB 1047 in 2024, which would have required testing of large models for catastrophic risks.
Online Reactions to the California AI Safety Post
Some users criticized Newsom’s record in California, with one writing, “Gavin Newsom has FAILED California on literally everything,” and another stating, “You can’t spell CATASTROPHE without CA. California is a 24/7 dumpster fire.”
Others focused on his earlier veto, noting, “This is exactly the problem: big talk about AI regulation, but when SB 1047 reached his desk, Newsom vetoed it.”
A number of replies questioned the state’s ability to manage the issue, including comments such as, “You are a failure to Californians,” and “Gavin can’t even keep the storm drains functional. Everything Gavin does turns into disaster.”
Experts tied to the recommendations offered a different view. Alondra Nelson, a former acting director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, said, “That irresponsible culture cannot continue. I was proud to work with Governor Newsom and his team to advance the same standard that Americans rightfully expect from every other sector: no experimenting on the public.”
Jason Goldman, who served as the first White House Chief Digital Officer, stated, “This report tackles the hardest open questions in AI safety regulation, including how emergency shutdown of a frontier model would work in practice.”
The exchange adds another moment to the ongoing debate over who should set rules for artificial intelligence as California advances its recommendations and federal policy remains limited.







