Close Menu
  • Gaming
    • Platforms
      • Nintendo
      • PC
      • PlayStation
      • Xbox
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Royals
  • Celebrity
    • Hollywood
  • Human Interest
  • Astrology
  • More
    • Reviews
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube
  • About Us
  • Join Our Team
  • Meet the Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertising Policy
The Nerd Stash
  • Gaming
  • Celebrity
  • Hollywood
  • Human Interest
The Nerd Stash
Home»Viral Stories»Lawyer Uses ChatGPT for Murder Appeal and Ends Up Inventing Witnesses Who Never Existed

Lawyer Uses ChatGPT for Murder Appeal and Ends Up Inventing Witnesses Who Never Existed

Laziness on another level

AugustBy AugustOctober 1, 20262 Mins Read
ChatGPT Logo
Image Source: Dima Solomin via Unsplash

As a lawyer, the last place you’d want to slip up is in the courtroom when your defendant’s fate is at stake. Unfortunately for New Mexico attorney Stephen Aarons, the courtroom was exactly where he messed things up for his career. And it was much more than an accidental slip of the tongue; he had ChatGPT create a list of “wholly fabricated witnesses” while attempting to do a murder appeal for his defendant.

You've heard of AI-hallucinated cases and quotes.

Now try hallucinated witnesses and testimony from them!

From New Mexico, here's an order where a lawyer admitted ChatGPT wrote the briefs; made up cases, people, and testimony; and he didn't check any of it. pic.twitter.com/noRgARPOC0

— Rob Freund (@RobertFreundLaw) September 30, 2026

Aarons thought ChatGPT could save him some time and give him an accurate summary of his case to share with the New Mexico Supreme Court. But according to Reuters, he hadn’t taken into account the risks of an LLM “hallucinating” evidence, essentially making things up. Even the justices couldn’t believe a lawyer going into a murder case in 2026 wouldn’t know about the mistakes AI can generate when it’s attempting to compile information.

The lawyer was now guilty of submitting lies to the court and even admitted to saying he didn’t check in with his defendant beforehand to ensure anything was accurate. His excuse is that his defendant is currently in prison and only speaks Spanish, but the judge wasn’t having it, accusing Aarons of being intentionally misinformed and taking a gamble with a case that has someone’s life on the line.

All this could have been avoided had Aarons done a quick glance over ChatGPT’s summary and list of witnesses before taking it to court. However, his refusal to do a basic double-check of the information says a lot about his lack of competence in court, and the Supreme Court is punishing him for it.

Related: New Mexico Sonic Worker Says Customers Were Accidentally Served Ranch Milkshakes for an Entire Night, but ‘Nobody Complained’

The New Mexico attorney was fined $5,000, removed from the case, and referred to the state’s attorney disciplinary board, all because he tried to take a careless shortcut with ChatGPT. It wasn’t a mistake to use an AI tool to make his job easier; it was a mistake to trust his entire career to it without checking facts himself.

Related Topics
New Mexico
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Reddit Email
August

August Webb is a Staff Writer and former Lead Guide Editor of TNS. When not working, she's playing a visual novel, fanning over an indie gem, or lost in the world of VR.

SUGGESTED READS

Prince Harry procession to Lying-in-State of Elizabeth II
Viral Stories

‘When Ukraine ​Wins, We Will ​Be Ready’: Prince Harry Accused of Using Ukraine Veterans for Invictus Games PR to Compete with Prince William’s Earthshot Trip

kingfisher on a tree stump
Viral Stories

‘We’re Talking About a Child’: Prince William’s Son’s Drawing Sparks Backlash as Art Teacher Slams Adults Attacking 13-Year-Old

Kate Middleton Waving in a Car
Viral Stories

‘Nature for Me but Not for Thee’: Kate Middleton Accused of ‘Making Cancer Her New Personality’ as Windsor Park Controversy Resurfaces

Meghan Markle and Piers Morgan
Viral Stories

‘Where’s Piers?’: Meghan Markle’s Father Sent Back to Jail as Reddit Critics Revisit Years of Estrangement Backlash

Trump Solar Project Canceled
Viral Stories

‘Congress Should Sue the President’: People Are Furious After Discovering Trump Allegedly Sabotaged a Solar Project to Help Low-Income Communities

DOJ Election Monitors 2026
Viral Stories

‘The DOJ Is Trump’s Personal Law Firm’: Voters Furious After The Department of Justice Stations Election Monitors Everywhere

The Nerd Stash
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
  • About Us
  • Join Our Team
  • Meet the Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertising Policy
© 2026 The Nerd Stash. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.