New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is no stranger to criticism, and now he’s facing another wave of online backlash after announcing plans to disband a controversial NYPD unit responsible for counterterrorism operations and protest response. Critics are questioning whether the move could leave New York vulnerable. The announcement also sparked comparisons between Mamdani and former Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein, especially with the mayor’s new mustache.
Mamdani announced Monday, November 16, that he was fulfilling a campaign promise to eliminate the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG), a specialized unit established in 2015 that has faced years of criticism over its handling of demonstrations. “Today, we are keeping that promise,” Mamdani said in a video announcing the decision.
The mayor and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said the changes would separate counterterrorism operations from protest policing while introducing new measures focused on communication and de-escalation. Under the new arrangement, the SRG’s counterterrorism responsibilities, including heavy weapons deployments at critical infrastructure, will move to the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau.
The administration will also establish a civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division, which will have neither weapons nor arrest powers. Meanwhile, a new First Amendment Support Team will consist of 30 uniformed officers trained to communicate with demonstrators. The reforms will also prohibit tear gas, kettling, and long guns during protests. Officers will no longer be permitted to use pepper spray as a crowd-control measure.
Mamdani’s Police Overhaul Concerns and Saddam Comparisons
While civil rights advocates have welcomed the changes, the New York Police Benevolent Association criticized the decision, warning that it could compromise public safety. Online, however, much of the reaction focused on Mamdani‘s appearance, with several critics comparing his mustache to Saddam Hussein’s. “He is channeling Saddam [Hussein],” accuses one commenter.
“Pretty sure that Stalin is a more apt comparison and the look he is likely going for,” one user wrote. Another commented, “Why does he suddenly resemble Saddam Hussein?” Others joined in with jokes about the mayor’s facial hair. “Mustaches are evil now,” one person quipped, while another wrote, “I thought it was an SNL skit at first, or a Sacha Baron Cohen skit.”
The security implications of the decision also attracted criticism. “Good luck NYPD,” one user wrote in response to the restrictions on tear gas and pepper spray. Another questioned the decision to replace a specialized police unit with a civilian-led division that cannot make arrests.
Mamdani’s administration, however, insists the overhaul will not weaken the department’s counterterrorism capabilities. The changes are also expected to come without additional funding or increases or reductions in NYPD staffing. Tisch defended the restructuring, saying the changes would make the department “stronger” and more effective while preserving its ability to protect New Yorkers.







