Texas Rep. Brandon Gill has weighed in on New York City’s decision to disband the New York Police Department’s Strategic Response Group (SRG), a special police unit responsible for counterterrorism operations and managing large protests. During an appearance on Fox News this week, Gill criticized Mayor Zohran Mamdani, claiming the move would make New York “less safe.” He also questioned why Mamdani, the city’s “first Muslim mayor,” would disband the counterterrorism unit after New York had suffered the September 11 terrorist attacks.
The Republican lawmaker’s remarks during the interview earned him some backlash from netizens. Many accused him of twisting the facts and trying to use Mamdani’s religion to fearmonger.
Mamdani announced the decision on Monday, November 16, alongside City Council member Chi Ossé, with the support of Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch. During his mayoral campaign, Mamdani promised to disband the SRG, stating that counterterrorism officers should not also police protesters.
The unit was created in 2015 to help the police department respond to terrorist threats and major emergencies. Its officers were also responsible for managing large crowds during demonstrations, preventing violence, and making arrests when necessary.
However, the unit has faced complaints for years over how its officers handled protests. SRG officers have been accused of using excessive force against demonstrators, including during the protests that followed George Floyd’s death in 2020.
The mayor’s office announced plans to separate the unit’s responsibilities. Rather than eliminating the NYPD’s counterterrorism operations, the department will transfer that work to another police bureau while creating a different system for handling protests.
‘They’re Defunding the Police’
Gill, however, questioned why Mamdani had waited until after the midterm elections to announce the decision. He suggested that the mayor knew the policy would be unpopular with voters.
“What I think is really interesting here is that Mamdani waited until after the elections to make these moves, because I think he knows how bad this looks, how bad this policy is,” Gill said during the interview.
He continued, “And that people across the country are going to be looking at New York and saying, ‘Listen, Democrats are doing here what they’re saying they’re gonna do: they’re defunding the police, they’re making the city significantly less safe.'”
The congressman then brought up the 9/11 terrorist attacks, which killed nearly 3,000 people, including many in New York City. He said it was not “lost on anybody” that 25 years after the attacks, the city had its “first Muslim mayor” disbanding one of the NYPD’s main counterterrorism units.
What Mamdani’s NYPD Changes Actually Mean
Mamdani’s announcement did not include plans to reduce the number of NYPD officers or eliminate the department’s counterterrorism work.
Instead, the city plans to move the SRG’s counterterrorism responsibilities to the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. That bureau will continue handling potential terrorist threats and deploying heavily armed officers to protect important locations across New York.
The mayor’s office also said work on the changes began in January, months before the November midterm elections.
These details were among the reasons many people on X disagreed with Gill’s description of the decision.
Some accused him of making it sound as though Mamdani was eliminating the NYPD’s counterterrorism operations, even though that work would continue under another bureau.
“I’m no fan of Mamdani, but why are you lying to your followers?” one commenter asked. Another wrote, “Can’t you criticize it based on what it is, rather than your fake framing?”
Others criticized Gill for bringing up the mayor’s religion while discussing the 9/11 attacks. They accused him of being prejudiced against Muslims.
“It shouldn’t be lost on anyone that you’re deliberately misrepresenting what happened while making the mayor’s religion the centerpiece of your argument,” one person claimed.
“Stop with the Islamophobia. You’ve misrepresented the whole story,” another said. A third added, “I guess you didn’t get the message…. racism isn’t working for you guys anymore.”
How the NYPD Plans to Handle Protests Without the SRG
Under the new plan, the city will create a civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division. Its job will be to communicate with protest organizers and work with police to prevent disagreements or confrontations from turning violent.
The NYPD will also establish a First Amendment Support Team consisting of 30 uniformed officers trained to communicate with protesters and calm tense situations. The team will work alongside the civilian division and help coordinate with officers responsible for crowd management.
Unlike the police officers assigned to crowd management, the civilian team will not carry weapons or have the power to make arrests.
The administration also plans to restrict certain police tactics during demonstrations, including banning the use of tear gas, long guns, and kettling, a tactic in which police surround protesters and prevent them from leaving an area. Officers will no longer be allowed to use pepper spray as a general crowd-management tool, while other methods of managing demonstrations will face tighter restrictions.







