A black woman in Colorado is alleging racial discrimination after police detained her and kept her in handcuffs for 22 minutes over a package that was later discovered to have never been stolen.
The woman, identified as Ebony Watson, has filed a lawsuit against three Denver Police Department officers following an incident on March 3. According to 9NEWS, which originally reported the story, Watson was wrongly accused of stealing a package from her apartment complex before officers discovered that they had detained the wrong person.
According to a police report provided to 9NEWS by Watson’s attorney, officers initially spoke with the resident who reported the alleged theft. The resident informed them that surveillance footage of the incident was available.
The officers then spoke with a leasing agent, who identified Watson as the suspected thief and wrote her apartment number on a sticky note. After reviewing the surveillance footage, the officers went to Watson’s apartment and knocked on her door.
Police Confronted Watson Over the Missing Package
Recalling the encounter during an interview with 9NEWS, Watson said, “When I open the door, it was like aggression automatically.”
Body camera footage showed the officers insisting that Watson had stolen the package, even though they appeared uncertain whether she was the person shown in the surveillance footage. At one point, two of the three officers stepped around a corner to review the recording again. During their discussion, the officers muted their body camera microphones. They eventually returned to Watson and instructed her to place her hands behind her back before placing her in handcuffs.
Watson recalled hearing her 8-year-old son screaming inside the apartment while officers detained her. She also expressed distress over the fact that her children and other residents were witnessing the encounter. “My main thing was my kids,” Watson explained. She described how her children watched the situation unfold while other residents walked past and saw her being detained. The officers then escorted Watson outside and placed her in the back seat of a patrol vehicle.
Officers Realized They Had Detained the Wrong Woman
While Watson remained inside the police vehicle, two officers returned to the apartment complex’s office because they were having difficulty identifying the woman in the surveillance footage. One significant difference was the woman’s hairstyle. The officers pointed out that the person in the recording appeared to have red dreadlocks, while Watson did not.
The apartment manager then checked the mailroom’s key fob records and identified another resident named Ebony. He asked the officers whether they had gone to a different apartment, leading them to realize that Watson had been mistakenly identified. “No wonder she’s crying,” one of the officers said after discovering the mistake.
The two officers subsequently muted their body camera microphones again as they walked back toward the patrol vehicle. They eventually released Watson, who said she was experiencing a panic attack and had already vomited out of the side of the police vehicle.
One of the officers acknowledged that they had received incorrect information from the apartment complex’s leasing staff. “We were provided information from leasing that was obviously bad information,” the officer explained.
The officer also described speaking with another employee who recognized that the identification had been incorrect. By the time Watson was released, she had reportedly spent 22 minutes in handcuffs.
The Supposedly Stolen Package Was Found the Following Day
Although Watson was released after officers realized their mistake, the situation raised further questions when the supposedly stolen package was found the following day. According to a detective’s follow-up report, the apartment manager contacted police after conducting a full audit of the mailroom, during which the missing package was located.
Watson’s attorney, Ben DeGolia, criticized the officers for failing to conduct a more thorough investigation before detaining her. He argued that police should have verified the allegation instead of relying solely on information provided by the apartment complex.
“Without a doubt, they’re going to point the finger at the property management company here and say they gave us bad information,” DeGolia told 9NEWS. However, he maintained that the officers were responsible for independently investigating the accusation rather than simply accepting the information they had received.
DeGolia also pointed out that there were basic investigative steps the officers could have taken before approaching Watson. For example, they could have checked whether a package was actually missing from the mailroom or reviewed Watson’s key fob records to determine whether she had entered the area on the day of the alleged theft.
“They could have gone into the mailroom to see if there was in fact a package missing,” DeGolia said. He added that Watson had not entered the mailroom that day, further questioning the basis for the officers’ decision to detain her.
Watson Files Lawsuit Alleging Racial Discrimination and Excessive Force
Following the incident, Watson filed a lawsuit against the three officers, alleging wrongful arrest, excessive force, and racial discrimination. The excessive force allegation concerns the officers’ use of handcuffs, which Watson alleges aggravated a pre-existing wrist injury.
Her attorney also argued that the officers treated Watson differently because of her race. He described the alleged discrimination as a violation of the equal protection clause under the Colorado Constitution.
DeGolia suggested that the encounter would have unfolded differently if the person answering the apartment door had been a white woman. He argued that, at worst, such a person would have received a citation rather than being detained.
The attorney maintained that officers had a responsibility to investigate the accusation properly instead of relying entirely on the identification provided by the apartment complex. Meanwhile, Watson described how the encounter continued to affect her even after her release.
She explained that she had become afraid to answer her apartment door without knowing who was outside. She described how the detention had affected her sense of safety. “I just need people to understand, like, the the effect that it had on my life. It changed me so much,” Watson told 9NEWS.
The Denver Police Department told 9NEWS Investigates that its review of the officers’ actions during the incident was still ongoing. The department also said it does not comment on pending litigation.
Watson’s lawsuit alleges that the officers violated her rights during an investigation into a package that was eventually found in the mailroom. Her allegations of wrongful arrest, excessive force, and racial discrimination remain claims in pending litigation. There is no court ruling establishing whether the officers violated her rights.
Outrage After Black Colorado Woman Is Mistakenly Arrested
Many viewers online expressed outrage after learning that the black woman in Colorado had been detained over a crime she did not commit. They criticized the officers involved, accusing them of rushing to conclusions without properly investigating the situation. “‘Quick! Let’s arrest the first black person we see!’ They couldn’t even handle being wrong,” one person wrote.
Another commenter expressed sympathy for Watson and criticized how the officers treated her. “Horrible to see her being made so vulnerable. It goes to show how precious human dignity is and police should be able to do their jobs without threatening our self worth. I hope she regains her confidence, because being made to feel like a perpetrator in front of your neighbors must be such a horrible experience,” they wrote.
Others continued to express outrage over the incident, criticizing the officers’ conduct and accusing them of abusing their authority. “[Expletive] police. [Expletive] [expletive] with inferiority complexes that juwt want to boss people around,” one person wrote.
Another commenter accused the officers of making assumptions based on race. In addition to failing to pay attention to differences between Watson and the person in the surveillance footage. “That and a lot of them mentally lazy. They see someone close enough to the suspect description and thats good enough for them. Doesn’t matter the suspect has different color hair, just arrest any black woman with dreads. That’s good enough,” they said.
The incident has raised concerns about racial discrimination and police accountability. This is in addition to the consequences of failing to properly investigate accusations before detaining someone. For Watson, what began as a mistaken identification turned into a distressing encounter. While her lawsuit remains pending, the case has prompted questions about whether the officers could have prevented the situation. This is through taking basic investigative steps and verifying the information they received.







