Comedian Andrew Schulz, who currently lives in New York, is facing renewed criticism from all over the political spectrum after calling President Donald Trump the “greatest failure of a president” in his lifetime, despite previously voting for him and giving him a massive platform during the 2024 presidential campaign. After 2024, Schulz also gradually ramped up his criticism of Trump, which has now turned into sharp remarks after Democrats have won Congress.
Schulz made the remarks during Saturday’s episode of Brilliant Idiots, the podcast he co-hosts with Charlamagne tha God. His comments marked another escalation in his increasingly public criticism of Trump, whom he once welcomed onto his popular Flagrant podcast. “It’s the greatest failure of a president of our lifetime,” Schulz said, before describing Trump’s presidency as “the greatest fall from grace, miscalculation, the greatest failure.”
He also accused the administration of doing the opposite of what Trump promised voters, pointing to what he described as unprecedented levels of corruption and cronyism. “What is more rare is literally doing the exact opposite of the things that you campaign on, to a level that nobody’s seen before and a level of corruption and cronyism that has never been seen in Western democracy,” he added.
From Trump Supporter to One of His Loudest Critics
Schulz’s comments have attracted attention partly because of his previous role in helping Trump reach younger male voters. In October 2024, the comedian hosted Trump for a roughly 90-minute interview on Flagrant. The episode attracted nearly 10 million views on YouTube. Schulz subsequently confirmed that he voted for Trump in the 2024 election.
However, he later explained that his vote was largely a rejection of the Democratic establishment rather than an endorsement of conservative ideology. He also described himself as a lifelong registered Democrat. By July 2025, Schulz was already expressing frustration with Trump’s policies, particularly government spending and foreign conflicts.
“I voted for none of this,” he said at the time, arguing that the president had abandoned several of the promises that attracted his support. His latest remarks attracted some critical reactions online, with some social media users questioning why he had not recognized Trump’s record sooner. “If he didn’t notice this two years ago, what is it now that’s changed?” one commenter asked.
Another suggested that podcast personalities were simply following political popularity, writing, “When Trump appeared popular and had the masses behind him, these podcast clowns were right there with him. Now that he’s unpopular, these same podcast clowns are running away.” Others were less sympathetic, arguing that Schulz and similar influencers helped create the political environment they now criticize.
“He’s a symptom AND a cause,” one user argued. Another commenter questioned the timing of the comedian’s change in position, suggesting it could be connected to his growing entertainment career. Not everyone accepted Schulz’s criticism as a genuine change of heart. Some argued that his previous support should not be forgotten simply because he is now publicly distancing himself from the president.







