Close Menu
  • Gaming
    • Platforms
      • Nintendo
      • PC
      • PlayStation
      • Xbox
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Royals
  • Celebrity
    • Hollywood
  • Human Interest
  • Astrology
  • More
    • Anime
    • Reviews
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube
  • About Us
  • Join Our Team
  • Meet the Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertising Policy
The Nerd Stash
  • Gaming
  • Celebrity
  • Hollywood
  • Human Interest
The Nerd Stash
Home»Human Interest»San Diego Teen Band Wows Crowd With Paramore Cover: ‘First 5 Seconds, 100% Thought This Was Hayley’

San Diego Teen Band Wows Crowd With Paramore Cover: ‘First 5 Seconds, 100% Thought This Was Hayley’

She sounds so incredible

Nat CollazoBy Nat CollazoOctober 15, 20252 Mins Read
San Diego Teen Band Wows Crowd With Paramore Cover 'First 5 Seconds, 100% Thought This Was Hayley'
Image Source: carolynnewtson TikTok via The Nerd Stash

At some point, every teen dreams of picking up an instrument to feel just a bit like their favorite band or artist. Growing up, I learned how to play the guitar because I thought that Kurt Cobain’s simple chord progressions and melancholy voice would be easy for me to learn (it wasn’t). Because of this, I already knew that I had no business covering any song by Paramore because, well, Hayley Williams is a goddess. One teenager in San Diego, California, decided to bring her teenage bandmates together to let her high school know that if you can dream it, then you really can do it.

@carolynnewtson

FULL VIDEO of my 15-year old niece singing @Paramore at her high school with her band @Flailing Idiot featuring @miya.mouse_ @Lillee and @SAMMIE AUGUSTO!! Closed out the show as the headlining band! So proud of you girls!!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼❤️ #rockthehill #missionvistahighschool #paramore #flailingidiot #socalpunk

♬ original sound – Carolyn Newtson

The above video features the all-girl band Flailing Idiot, at what appears to be either a talent show or a Battle of the Bands at a local high school. The song being performed by the girls is the incredibly vocal-heavy All I Wanted Was You by the pop-punk band Paramore. For those unaware, that particular song is very difficult to sing, even for the most gifted singers, and can likely only be done by talented lead singers like Hayley Williams herself. However, just as the song reached the pivotal lyrical moment, the lead singer of Flailing Idiot, 15-year-old Sammie Augusto, absolutely wowed the crowd with her insane vocals. She did such an incredible job that one of the top comments under the video said, “First 5 seconds, 100% thought this was Hayley.“

Flailing Idiot has been a massive pinnacle in the pop-punk scene as of late, with Sammie’s mother posting a different performance the band had done last year. Last year, Flailing Idiot performed Still Into You, also by Paramore, to a crowd who very much in awe of the entire performance. You can really hear the vocal powerhouse that Sammie is, with her bandmates playing their instruments in perfect harmony around her.

San Diego Locals Celebrate Wes the ‘Bubble Man’ Who Blows Bubbles to Help Drivers Slow Down Near a School: ‘The World Needs More of This Right Now’
Related: San Diego Locals Celebrate Wes the ‘Bubble Man’ Who Blows Bubbles to Help Drivers Slow Down Near a School: ‘The World Needs More of This Right Now’

Of course, Sammie isn’t the only incredible artist in the band. The other members, Miya Schultheis, and Lillee Gillum are also teenagers who go to the same school. The girls also have original songs, which mimic the high-energy and general internet presence of the various bands that clearly inspired them. I wish I had a group of friends who were this talented when I was going to high school! More than anything, I can’t wait for Flailing Idiot to become as worldwide as they deserve.

Related Topics
California human interest
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Reddit Email
Nat Collazo
  • Website
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram

I am a game journalist and guide writer with ten years of experience as well as the CEO/ Founder of Frowns Marketing, a marketing company that caters to indie games, tabletop games, and board games to help developers get more wishlists, backers, and players!

SUGGESTED READS

Utah Mom of Disabled Children Finds Out How Judgmental People Can Be When Confronted by Nosy Karen
Human Interest

Crazy Utah Karen Confronts Disabled Children And Mom Can’t Believe It: ‘The audacity of some people’

Georgia Activist Demonstrates Consent to a Class of Young Boys in Viral Video 'Can you hold a lesson at a college frat'
Human Interest

Georgia Activist Demonstrates Consent to a Class of Young Boys in Viral Video: ‘Can you hold a lesson at a college frat?’

Connecticut Woman Calls Cops On Karen Trying To Steal Chickens
Human Interest

Connecticut Woman Calls Cops On Cuckoo Karen Trying To Steal Chickens: ‘You Never Even Asked Their Names’

Utah Woman Gets Crazy Letters From Neighbor
Human Interest

Utah Single Mother Gets Crazy Letters From Delusional Neighbor: ‘I Can Promise You A Delicious Beans Dinner’

Colorado Woman Shares 90s Time Capsule From the Day She Survived Columbine: 'The paper with the date 4/20/99 gave me chills'
Human Interest

Utah Woman Shares 90s ‘Time Capsule’ From the Day She Survived Columbine: ‘The paper with the date 4/20/99 gave me chills’

Human Interest

Man’s Victory Moment in Delaware Marathon Ends in Tears After Last-Minute Takoever: ‘The Last Shall Be First, You Hear Me!’

The Nerd Stash
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
  • About Us
  • Join Our Team
  • Meet the Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertising Policy
© 2026 The Nerd Stash. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.