Fans have been trying to grab the perfect story surrounding “RHOLSC” Heather Gay’s black eye, and talk show host Andy Cohen might just have cracked it!— his theory points to Jen Shah, but how true is that?
After a night of fun, glam, and music, Heather Gay’s black eye shocked cast members and viewers as she returned the next day with the look.
This scar refused to clear up, and ultimately, it sparked an intense discussion among the cast members and on social media platforms.
At first, “RHOLSC” Heather Gay’s black eye story was that she knew how it came about, but wanted the perpetrator to own up. She confided in her cousin, Whitney Rose, revealing:
“I think we all know what happened, I just think we don’t want to talk about it.”
Much later, the “Bad Mormon” publisher maintained her memory of the event was foggy, and she wanted to close the topic.
Weeks after a back-and-forth and a futile investigation conducted by Bravo network, Andy Cohen points fingers at Jen Shah.
Andy Cohen Calls BS!He thinks Jen Shah gave Heather Gay the black eye! – Perez Hiltonhttps://t.co/aOEdPg3O9Y
— Business News (@Busines65959783) February 17, 2023
“RHOLSC” Heather Gay’s Black Eye Caused By Jen Shah, Says Cohen
Weeks after “RHOLSC” Heather Gay’s black eye became the sensational gossip in the house, the “Watch What Happens Live” host gives his two cents. Cohen, who welcomed Lala Kent on his Wednesday episode, talked about the incident. Kent mentioned it must have been from a cast member.
The talk show host gave the nod to her theory before adding a name and discrediting Gay’s claim. In his words:
“From Jen Shah? I do too. I don’t think she hit her head on a cabinet and got scratches on her arm.”
As mentioned earlier, Gay affirmed she knew the unfiltered truth and would not like to call out the culprit. Afterward, she messaged Shah. Jen Shah and Heather Gay sat face to face plotting a cover story because, in her opinion, she did not want to stir trouble for anyone.
But Cohen’s theory of Shah attacking Gay was echoed in Rose’s statement. She believed Shah was responsible. Rose opined that Gay might know this but has refused to come clean, thinking it would affect Shah’s trial— she has been sentenced to 6.5 years.
“RHOLSC” Heather Gay’s black eye debate occurred simultaneously with Shah’s court appearances. Earlier in the year, she pleaded guilty to a fraud charge. Last July, she was convicted for her role in a telemarketing plot. Shah gave up $6.5 million and will pay $9.5 million in indemnity as part of her plea agreement.