Close Menu
  • Gaming
    • Game Guides
    • Codes
    • Game News
    • Game Previews
    • Game Reviews
    • Game Features
    • Game Lists
    • Platforms
      • Nintendo
      • PC
      • PlayStation
      • Xbox
      • Mobile
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • Movie Features
    • Movie Reviews
    • TV
    • Reality TV
    • Royals
  • Celebrity
  • Human Interest
  • Astrology
  • Videos
  • More
    • Anime
    • Lists
    • Podcasts
    • Reviews
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube
  • About Us
  • Join Our Team
  • Meet the Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertising Policy
The Nerd Stash
  • Gaming
  • Celebrity
  • Human Interest
  • Videos
The Nerd Stash
Home»Features»Watership Down: The Sinking City Reaction, Explored

Watership Down: The Sinking City Reaction, Explored

Making fish-heads or monkey-tails of The Sinking City and its reputation amongst the gaming community is a mystery befitting an H.P Lovecraft story. Reviews vary…

Nerd Stash StaffBy Nerd Stash StaffJune 21, 20196 Mins Read
The Sinking City
This article is over 6 years old and may contain outdated information.

Making fish-heads or monkey-tails of The Sinking City and its reputation amongst the gaming community is a mystery befitting an H.P Lovecraft story. Reviews vary wildly, from a 3/10 (Gamespot) all the way up to a perfect score (ComicBook).ย  The Metacritic is a study in confusion. How does this happen?

Opinions vary, but traditionally when scores are like this, with a vocal group of players championing the game in the face of negativity, there’s probably something worth exploring there.ย 

Well, let’s start with this: In my dozen or so hours with the game, I…do not particularly like The Sinking City. But, I still think it’s a pretty good game.

See, here’s the thing: The Sinking City is a grimy little gem of a title, and you have to be up for this thing to truly enjoy it. It doesnโ€™t hold your hand. Itโ€™s gross, dirty, brown, dour, and creepy. There are little bugs who seem to be made entirely of human arms scurrying about, folks that look like fish, others that look like primates, and intentional warping of the game screen. Oh yeah, almost forgot to mention that everything is drenched in water and damp, and a dusting of sadly era-appropriate racism.ย 

The Sinking City

For the uninformed, The Sinking City is an open-world investigation game, tasking player-character Charles Reed with uncovering the mystery of the haunting, visceral visions that have drawn him and others to the port town of Oakmont Massachusetts – home to an off-putting bunch of citizens, and quite a few strange happenings. Gameplay wise, youโ€™ll travel across multiple districts, read files, reconstruct crime scenes, pixel hunt, and rotate all manner of evidence in your quest for answers. All of this is in service of making conclusions and deductions on a given case, many of which are gray in nature and give the player a sort of โ€œDid I do that wrong?โ€ anxiety, which is typically a positive sign of a good story well told.ย 

Admittedly, this feels a little drawn out as you move across various districts, houses, and offices for clues. You are also searching for evidence and there are key characters you need to speak to. Backtracking, getting lost, scouring a room for that one, final, tiny piece of evidence on the back of a picture, the gang is all here. Thereโ€™s some variety in the various parts of the town, but I suspect there will be no bright yellow giraffes to greet me at the end of this journey.

(Thereโ€™s also some glitches of NPCs appearing out of nowhere, or standing where they shouldnโ€™t, along with occasional, confusing overlapping audio.)

The Sinking City

Yet outside of those glitches and bugs, all of this feels like a choice. Unlike other games that want you to play in their โ€˜living, breathingโ€™ worlds for hours, The Sinking Cityโ€™s Oakmont is brave in its goals of agitating the player with its oppressively depressing nature. You donโ€™t want to be there, they donโ€™t want you there, but you have to be there, and in your humble authorโ€™s opinion, the gameplay (and its frustrations) serves that notion.ย 

That is not most playersโ€™ version of a good time. In the same way most movie fans will use the term โ€˜sadโ€™ or โ€˜depressingโ€™ as a negative when describing a powerful film that didnโ€™t feed them a constant stream of smiling dopamine sugar cubes, The Sinking City isnโ€™t โ€˜funโ€™ in the traditional sense of the word.ย Fascinating. Strange. Unique. Depressing. Oppressing. These are the adjectives that describe The Sinking City and they do not make for a crowd-pleaser.

Then again, Bright Eyes, Elliot Smith, and Marilyn Manson arenโ€™t exactly everyoneโ€™s cup of tea either.ย  And that’s fine, too.ย If you’re a reviewer for a major, mainstream outlet, the score you’reย required to give a game is the thing folks look at most and often times first. For a game about mysteries, quantifying the quality of this game, for that audience, is quite the conundrum.

It’s a matter of taste ultimately. My favorite games are sometimes janky, predatory, and weird. From Madden Ultimate Team to Yakuzaย to My Time at Portia, games can be so very different from one another and still compel you to play them. In fact,ย My Time at Portiaย has a similar, drawn-out gameplay loop. But, it’s bright and colorful.ย  There are cute animals, mining, and you grow stuff. Those specific elements made the drawn-out open world nature of the gameplay a lot of fun and very rewarding, whereas a similar loop in The Sinking Cityย is something very different.

Similarly, Murdered: Soul Suspect, a game not completely unlike this one, also received middling to poor reviews upon release but found itself enjoyed by a lot of gamers who discovered it on their own. Reviews be damned…or burnt at the stake I guess.

The Sinking City

So, no, The Sinking City isnโ€™t an appealing game for most and absolutely doesnโ€™t want to be, either. Itโ€™s not the kind of horror thatโ€™s basically an action game with jump scares. It’s also not a low-resistance potboiler.ย  Itโ€™s an abrasive, unwelcoming, and challenging title when you get down to it. In this regard, the low(ish) review scores are understandable. While abrasive doesnโ€™t mean bad, it can be taken that way – no one is blasting Dimmu Borgir at Walmart for example. And if a game designed almost entirely around making the player feel caught in the worldโ€™s worst fever dream doesnโ€™t sound exactly like your idea of a good time, then, well, it wonโ€™t be.

But hereโ€™s the rub. I think if youโ€™re keen to pick up what this game is putting down in terms of atmosphere, character, and storytelling, youโ€™re liable to have a good time – flaws and all. You can’t have a polarizing reception without a lot of folks really liking a thing. And in the same way folks can enjoy pitch-black bleakness in their movies, music, and television, surely thereโ€™s an audience for that in gaming.ย 

I didnโ€™t enjoy The Sinking City. But I think that’s more of a me problem (along with lots of other people). This game works on you the player. Agitating you. Frustrating you. Creeping up your back with dread. That’s the point of it. The team has executed on their vision splendidly.ย 

Emotional masochists need games too, after-all.

Did you like The Sinking City? Let us know in the comments below!

Related Topics
Frogwares TheSinkingCity
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Reddit Email
Nerd Stash Staff
  • Website

SUGGESTED READS

Destiny 2 Weapon and Armor Tiers
Game Guides

How Do Weapon and Gear Tiers Work in Destiny 2: The Edge of Fate

Destiny 2 Edge of Fate Exotic Items
Game Guides

All Exotics in Destiny 2: The Edge of Fate

Destiny 2 Edge of Fate Power Level 200
Game Guides

How To Reach Power Level 200 Fast in Destiny 2: The Edge of Fate

Sean Diddy Combs
Celebrity

Diddy’s Former Protรฉgรฉe Aubrey Oโ€™Day Breaks Silence: Verdict ‘Makes Me Physically Ill’

Car driving recklessly
Human Interest

Driver Has Medical Emergency While On Busy Michigan Road, ‘Scary’ Footage Goes Viral

News

Georgia Singer Gavin Adcock Sparks Outrage Over Beyoncรฉ Country Comments: ‘Just Pop and Hiphop for Hicks Who Hate Black People’

Trending
Texas Man records a package thief stealing boxes off the porch

Texas Man Comes up With โ€˜Epicโ€™ Idea To Get Revenge on Porch Pirates: โ€˜This Is Genius’

Florida bride has special moment with two fathers at wedding

Florida Bride’s Father Shocks Guests At Wedding When He Sees Her Stepdad In Crowd: ‘Cries In Daddy Issues’

A picture of the Texas police impersonator.

Texas Police Impersonator Ambushes Couple and Ends Up Crawling For His Life: โ€˜He Literally Turned Into a Wormโ€™

MAGA Supporter With a Megaphone Harasses Safeway Protestors in Colorado

MAGA Supporter With a Megaphone Harasses Safeway Protestors in Colorado: ‘Couldn’t Even Make the Cut for ICE So He Had to Settle For This’

The Nerd Stash
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn
  • About Us
  • Join Our Team
  • Meet the Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Editorial Guidelines
  • Advertising Policy
© 2025 The Nerd Stash. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.