Skip To...
Carrie Underwood’s ascent to stardom began with her winning American Idol in 2005. Since then, she has established herself as one of the country music scene’s most successful and influential artists. With over 70 million records sold worldwide, multiple Grammy Awards, and a celebrated career spanning nearly two decades, Underwood has proven her talent and versatility. Twenty-five years after her life-changing victory, Carrie Underwood will return to American Idol as a judge. ABC made the announcement in July 2024, revealing that the singer would replace Katy Perry. Since the news became public, fans and aspiring musicians alike have wondered what she will bring to the show. Here are five things to expect from Carrie Underwood as an American Idol judge.
A Deep Understanding of the Contestants’ Journey
Carrie Underwood’s journey from a small-town girl to a superstar started on the American Idol stage. Being a contestant on the show at some point provides her with a unique perspective that few judges can offer. Underwood understands the pressure, challenges, and excitement of participating in a high-stakes competition like American Idol. This empathy and firsthand experience will most likely translate into a nurturing and supportive approach when dealing with contestants. With the singer able to relate to contestants’ struggles and dreams, she can offer invaluable encouragement and motivation. Ultimately, this will help contestants navigate the emotional rollercoaster of the American Idol experience.
Insight, Truth, and Constructive Criticism
Carrie Underwood started on American Idol as a young, inexperienced singer. But now, she boasts an enviable career spanning over two decades. With her extensive experience in the music industry, Carrie Underwood, as a judge, will surely bring a wealth of knowledge. She has not only honed her vocal abilities but also mastered stage presence, song selection, and audience engagement. Contestants can expect to receive constructive criticism that is insightful and actionable. Underwood emphasized being a truthful judge during a chat on GMA’s Summer Concert Series in August 2024.
“I have a problem. I can’t lie. I feel like I’ll be very honest but hopefully, I’ll be very constructive and encouraging,” she said.
Overall, Underwood’s feedback will likely focus on improving performance quality, vocal technique, and overall artistry.
Advocacy for Country Music
As a prominent figure in country music, Underwood is well-positioned to advocate for this genre on American Idol. While the show has historically embraced various musical styles, Carrie Underwood being on American Idol’s judging panel may bring a renewed focus on country music. Contestants with dreams of venturing into country music will find a strong ally in Underwood, who can offer genre-specific advice and support. Additionally, the icon’s influence may inspire a broader appreciation for country music among viewers and participants, thus enriching the show’s musical diversity.
Emphasis on Authenticity and Emotional Connection
One of the many things Underwood is known for is her ability to convey emotion and tell compelling stories through her music. Songs like Jesus, Take the Wheel, and Before He Cheats resonate deeply with audiences due to their powerful storytelling and emotional resonance. As a judge, the 41-year-old will likely emphasize the importance of authenticity and telling stories in performances. Underwood understands that technical proficiency alone is not enough and that connecting with the audience emotionally is crucial. Contestants can expect to be encouraged to dig deep into their personal experiences and channel those emotions into their performances. This focus on authenticity will not only make their stage presence better but also help them forge a deeper connection with the audience.
A Role Model for Aspiring Artists
Carrie Underwood’s journey from American Idol winner to global superstar is undeniably a powerful example for aspiring artists. Her dedication, resilience and unwavering commitment to her craft demonstrate what is possible with hard work and perseverance. As a judge, Underwood will undoubtedly inspire contestants to pursue their dreams with the same passion and determination. Her success story will always serve as a reminder that the American Idol stage can be a launching pad for a remarkable career. This, in turn, will motivate contestants to give their best and seize every opportunity that comes their way. As Carrie Underwood prepares to begin another American Idol journey as a judge in season 23, fans can expect a season filled with heartfelt performances, genuine mentorship, and unforgettable moments.
